h.e.s.e. project UK


www.hese-project.org/en/

Ethics, mass marketing and the use and implications of digital technologies

These are ‘stop and think’ pages, because the human trait to follow a techno-trail, eyes to the ground instead of up, is something we should have learned about, and have not. A reasonable question would be: is h.e.s.e. making biological risk of EM fields the only issue? What, besides, are the social and economic questions of a wireless world? Families? Youth culture? Dependency? Ability to plan? Addiction? Social control? Let’s think ahead a bit and talk.

2. Digital convergence and social control

Convergence: this is the merging of communications into a single system. Why not send TV, radio, data, phone calls, entertainment, finance, all through the same system? Why carry several gadgets, when one will do? Why store data in lots of places, when one safe place is better? Why have incompatible databases and devices, when one can be more efficient? Why have credit cards and text messaging from your bank, when the phone could be the credit card? Why have an ID card, and transact with government and tax via computer, when your phone is your id and you can be reached that way?

It is all quite reasonable and logical, efficient and beneficial. Isn’t it?

We therefore must have mobile phone, WiFi and broadband antennae of all sorts all around us for one simple reason: people use wireless devices, and they love them. Government and corporate interest find it extremely useful. Their use is justified by convenience, security, and ‘safety’ etc.

Just as a matter of interest, there is a radio-controlled dog (training / correction) collar available. Press a button on the radio control and the dog gets a graded shock. Dog trainers say they are cruel, the makers say they enhance safety: you can stop your dog running across the road, or stop it attacking ...)

Must we have everything mobile, and antennae all around us?

Mobile phone base stations are contentious, because of quite legitimate health concerns, since they are not remote deep countryside things (rather their range is diminishing). So, if they are not to be permitted outside blocks of flats, in direct proximity to bedroom windows, next to schools or mounted on hospitals, there are only three logical ways out:

  1. we stop using microwave, or digitally structured signals (or whatever it is that causes the biological incompatibility)
  2. we have so many mini-bases that there is always one near, wherever you go, and EM field levels are kept as low as possible
  3. we stop using wireless devices.

The first requires global redesign, after identifying (and accepting) where the problem begins. Maybe it is the extreme low frequency (ELF) pulsing. Maybe not: UMTS (3G) doesn’t do this in the same way at all, but still affects people. Either way, we are a long way off such a technology transformation, and better mast planning is no longer an answer.

The second may be around the corner: should we accept picocells everywhere?

The third option is disappearing rapidly into the impossible as dependency increases, or even is thrust upon us. For example, is this the future?

No, this isn’t new; a mobile can be a swipe card already in Japan. But it concerns the matter of convergence; the day will come when it may well be nigh impossible to buy, sell, travel, communicate, go anywhere – without a combined personal mobile id/communication device.

What will your ‘phone’ do?

If civilisation survives long enough, they won’t be phones like we have now (‘remember the RSI in our thumbs because the buttons had got so small?’), they will be on (or in?) some part of our anatomy and we will just talk to them; and trackers/RFID devices will read them as we go by. We will talk to them, they will talk to us, listen to us, inform us; tell us (advise us) what we can and cannot do:

You can probably think of more reasonable best-interest or national security examples. And remember another trend is towards remote possession of information, entertainment, software etc., ie, stored remotely and licensed into your home. No more stacks of old CDs; ‘your’ music will be time-rented. No more massive computer storage: why keep it and risk it at home for when your computer fails? Your Internet Service Provider will look after all your data needs far more securely. So include in ‘permitted access’ information, under your ‘need to know’ rights (not censorship per se, just keeping information that ‘wouldn’t be useful’ out of your/harm’s way ...).

The social control context

In the UK we have more surveillance cameras than anywhere in the world. Roadside cameras can monitor 35 million road journeys a day, and each can read numberplates. Head-on cameras can identify drivers. Vehicle trackers are used for road access and charging. Highly sensitive microphones may soon accompany cameras, and loudspeakers be able to give ‘instruction’.

Digital convergence, however, will mean that much more surveillance is there to be taken advantage of, in the form of the ubiquitous ‘personal id/communiator’, and messages (advice) sent directly to you. Why shout at everyone, if the CCTV can identify your phone and return the message (or fine) directly to you?

In times of unrest, such as when people really start moving as a result of climate change, the new mobile will doubtless prove very useful. Is the above so unlikely? Is it science fiction or is it logical progression? When it comes to making sure no-one can be where they should not be, able to commit a crime or act of terrorism, or enter or leave a country ... it all sounds so reasonable. And the convenience ...

Now ... what was it about the remote dog collar?

Links on mobiles tracking

Other ethical issues

[close this print window]

© 2009 The h.e.s.e. Project : Human Ecological Social Economic

Source URL: www.hese-project.org/hese-uk/en/niemr/ethics.php?id=social&style=print