Topical issues: the electromagnetic environment

With our modern environment full of electromagnetic fields, fom power transmision through to all forms of communication, the issues of how this affects our well-being are urgent.
 

Mobile phones and driving

This is clearly a significant safety issue. From one point of view it can be treated alongside other distracting technology in cars such as satellite navigation, music and radio, which when used passively present few problems, but when fiddled with can be dangerously distracting. But there is more to it than this, so needs to be also compared with conversations with passengers, or children fighting and arguing in the back seat! But it is even more than that too, because the conversation is held with someone unseen and unseeing, out of empathy with the changing driving situation. More importantly, the electromagnetic fields could also be a contributory factor if they alter brain function and attention in any way. Certainly mobiles should never be used in cars without an external antenna. This is important if vehicle tracking devices (for reasons such as road tolls or taxing) enter the realm of pasive GPS receiving (for position location) but GSM transmitting (for location reporting), from more or less continuous dashboard devices. It is also important if roadside RFID tag reading is used requiring high reading fields.

Whichever aspect of risk is/are true, driving is affected, and legislation has been enacted so that hand-held use of mobiles whilst driving is illegal.

Does the simple law match the research? No, not entirely; hands-free does not get a clean bill of health either.

The research

So far, studies fall into several types:

  • accident prevention: do modes (hands-free, hand-held) of mobile phone differentially use cause accidents?
  • accident analysis: is mobile use correlated with accident incidence, or particular types of accident?
  • attention studies: is there anything about talking to a remote caller that is different from talking to passengers or attending to other in-car systems?

These studies are undertaken in several ways:

  • desk research of available information
  • simulated driving conditions
  • observation of real driving situations.

Rather less has been done on field strengths in vehicles during a phone call session, or internal air ion balance etc. (probably because the distraction element is assumed to be the obvious primary effect) or in correlating these aspects alone (without the conversation) with attention, perceived significance, and error perception.

Into this mix it is therefore essential that we add research on attention and concentration during and following mobile phone calls, not just when driving. This requires examination of the electromagnetic effects on brain function, blood circulation, oxygenation etc., as well as just the aspects of divided attention, and aspects of attention required uniquely by remote calls rather than holding a phone (and driving with one hand!) or holding a conversation.

The main conclusion from all studies is that even though the ability to handle a remote call is an individual thing, and can perhaps be learned as a skill to some degree, the distraction factor appears to narrow the range of vision as attention is given preferentially to a slightly fragmented call where the other party does not share awareness of the immediate driving situation.

To cite Parkes and Burns 2002, MTHR: (pp.87-99):

‘Driving performance clearly suffers when the driver is performing a simultaneous task. The results of most driving measures showed similar fall off in performance for each of the three driving conditions. However, there was an interesting and important difference in reaction time results that showed the worst performance scores in the hands-free condition. This result was complemented by the subjective workload scores that showed hands-free conversation rated higher than in-vehicle tasks or talking to a passenger. By looking at the conversation itself, we have shown a distinct difference between talking over the carphone and talking to a passenger. There is an important difference between communicating with a passenger who is directly involved in the concurrent drive, and with one that is remote and uninvolved.’

  • Association between Cellular-Telephone Calls and Motor Vehicle Collisions (1997)
    has this extraordinary conclusion:

    ‘The use of cellular telephones in motor vehicles is associated with a quadrupling of the risk of a collision during the brief period of a call. Decisions about regulation of such telephones, however, need to take into account the benefits of the technology and the role of individual responsibility.’

These reports compare the quality of driving with the influence of alcohol:

More than just distraction:

An age effect? Ar an ageing effect?

EM fields and brain activity

Phones and accidents